Skip to main content

WGA, Teamsters & Other Unions Urge FTC to Contest Amazon-MGM’s Done Deal; Regulator Says It Can Challenge Mergers “Any Time”

No Time To Die
'No Time To Die' - the MGM Bond franchise is now Amazon's Nicola Dove

The Writers Guild of America Westand a coalition of unions launched another salvo against Amazon-MGM, urging antitrust watchdog, the Federal Trade Commission, to contest the deal even though it officially closed last week.

Their letter to the FTC today focused in part on Amazon’s acquiring MGM-owned Epix, taking out a producer and nascent streaming service, and it hit on previous arguments that the FTC must prevent Amazon from “consolidating power across the entertainment industry, reducing consumer choice and harming the creative workforce.”

“We strongly believe that this is an instance where the FTC must challenge a deal post-merger, because of the outsized role Amazon plays in our economy overall and how the merger would enhance Amazon’s ability to leverage its power against workers in the entertainment industry and across different platforms,” the groups said.

Amazon's MGM Acquisition Cleared By European Union In Key Approval

Under the banner of the Strategic Organizing Center, the other labor unions — representing over 4 million workers — include Service Employees International, International Brotherhood of Teamsters, Communications Workers of America and United Farmworkers of America.

The FTC doesn’t formally ‘approve’ deals. Rather, a time-clock for review starts when one is announced and can run out with the FTC either taking no action, or suing to block it – which requires a majority vote of commissioners. There are only four in place currently, reportedly split 2-2 along party lines on Amazon-MGM. The fifth commissioner awaits Senate approval.

FTC Chair Lina Khan, an aggressive antitrust enforcer, has written papers about risks posted by Amazon’s dominance and was asked by the company to recuse herself from a review but declined.

The merger closed March 17 — last Thursday. Asked for comment, the tight-lipped FTC noted that it can challenge a deal at any time.

“The FTC does not comment on any particular matters. However, we reiterate that the Commission does not approve transactions and may challenge a deal at any time if it determines that it violates the law,” a spokesperson said.

“Additionally, this summer the FTC announced that it will send pre-consummation warning letters in connection with deals it cannot fully investigate within the timelines established by the HSR Act. These letters alert merging parties that their transactions remain under investigation, and warn that consummation occurs at their own risk.” (The HSR, or Hart-Scott-Rodino, Act requires parties to proposed deals to submit premerger notification to the FTC and DOJ.)

Amazon decline to comment on the letter from WGAW et al, or on whether it had received a “pre-consummation” warning.

The FTC has sued to block completed deals a few times: In 2020, it voted 5-0 to sue to unwind Altria’s $12.3 billion investment in rival JUUL Labs. It sued Facebook the same year, alleging the social media giant had maintained a monopoly through a long course of anticompetitive conduct its 2012 acquisition of up-and-coming rival Instagram and its 2014 acquisition of mobile messaging app WhatsApp.

In Altria/JUUL, the case went to administrative court where a judge ruled to dismiss the complaint. The FTC staff has filed an appeal. ForFacebook, the case went to federal court where it had a rocky reception at first but litigation is ongoing.

Pundits generally have been skeptical there was much of an antitrust runway in the Amazon-MGM combination given competition in the streaming space and the fact that MGM, while a substantial studio, is no giant. Regulators allowed Comcast to buy NBCUniversal,Disney to buy Fox, and Discovery to merge with WarnerMedia, among others.

“The history of bad mergers that have been approved in media just shows the urgency to step up antitrust enforcement,” Laura Blum-Smith, WGAW Director of Research and Public Policy, told Deadline.

“Streaming has become very vertically integrated, with all of the major players focused on producing content for their own streaming services. That means less competition between employers of writers and others in the industry, higher barriers of entry for new entrants, and an industry pushed in a direction where more consolidation is very likely, where there could be just 3 or 4 streaming companies in a few years,” she said,

“That would be a terrible outcome for diversity of content, and this merger moves us further in that direction in multiple ways. It eliminates MGM’s Epix network, which is a competing buyer, increases vertical integration and it will prompt reactive consolidation as other companies rush to bulk up in response.”

WGAW was distressed by the Disney-Fox merger. In Dec. of 2017 it issued the following statement: “In the relentless drive to eliminate competition, big business has an insatiable appetite for consolidation. Disney and Fox have spent decades profiting from the oligopolistic control that the six major media conglomerates have exercised over the entertainment industry, often at the expense of the creators who power their television and film operations. Now, this proposed merger of direct competitors will make matters even worse by substantially increasing the market power of a combined Disney-Fox corporation. The antitrust concerns raised by this deal are obvious and significant. The Writers Guild of America West strongly opposes this merger and will work to ensure our nation’s antitrust laws are enforced.”

Last December, the guild published a report called Broken Promises: Media Mega-Mergers and the Case for Antitrust Reform. It called media “the poster child for the failures of antitrust enforcement” and said a wave of deals over the past 12 years have led to “lower wages, higher consumer prices, fewer or worse consumer choices, and less innovation.”

On Amazon-MGM, SOC sent a pair of letters to the FTC last year outlining the dangers that Amazon’s “aggressive anti-competitive conduct in the streaming industry poses across the distribution chain. ”WGAW had highlighted “threats to the creative workforce posed by an increasingly vertically and horizontally integrated entertainment industry.”

Today’s missive was sent to Holly Vedova, director of the FTC’s Competition Bureau, by Blum-Smith and Michael Zucker, SOC Executive Director. It slammed what it called “Amazon’s distorted, retail-driven goals.” The giant company has been upfront about using Prime Video as a gateway into its Amazon Prime customer loyalty program, the biggest in the world and the beating heart of the company.

The letter also noted “the latest criminal referral by the House Judiciary Committee to the Department of Justice stemming from Amazon’s allegedly false testimony before Congress.” Earlier this month, a bipartisan group of lawmakers asked the DOJ to open an investigation into Amazon and its executives for potentially criminal obstruction of Congress. It’s not about media, but they alleged the company “engaged in a pattern and practice of misleading conduct” in responding to lawmakers’ e-commerce related questions about its private-label practices and its collection of third-party seller data.

Popular posts from this blog

Yandex spins out self-driving car unit from its Uber JV, invests $150M into newco

Self-driving cars are still many years away from becoming a ubiquitous reality, but today one of the bigger efforts to build and develop them is taking a significant step out as part of its strategy to be at the forefront for when they do. Yandex — the publicly-traded Russian tech giant that started as a search engine but has expanded into a number of other, related areas (similar to US counterpart Google) — today announced that it is spinning out its self-driving car unit from MLU BV — a ride-hailing and food delivery joint venture it operates in partnership with Uber. The move comes amid reports that Yandex and Uber were eyeing up an IPO for MLU  last year. At the time, the JV was estimated to be valued at around $7.7 billion. It’s not clear how those plans will have been impacted in recent months, with COVID-19 putting huge pressure on ride-hailing and food-delivery businesses globally, and IPOs generally down compared to a year ago. In that context, spinning out the unit could

Slack’s new integration deal with AWS could also be about tweaking Microsoft

Slack and Amazon announced a big integration late yesterday afternoon. As part of the deal, Slack will use Amazon Chime for its call feature, while reiterating its commitment to use AWS as its preferred cloud provider to run its infrastructure. At the same time, AWS has agreed to use Slack for internal communications. Make no mistake, this is a big deal as the SaaS communications tool increases its ties with AWS, but this agreement could also be about slighting Microsoft and its rival Teams product by making a deal with a cloud rival. In the past Slack CEO Stewart Butterfield has had choice words for Microsoft saying the Redmond technology giant sees his company as an “existential threat.” Whether that’s true or not — Teams is but one piece of a huge technology company — it’s impossible not to look at the deal in this context. Aligning more deeply with AWS sends a message to Microsoft, whose Azure infrastructure services compete with AWS. Butterfield didn’t say that of course

Xbox One S vs. Xbox One X: Which should you buy?

http://bit.ly/2v1agl5 We live and breathe tech, and also gaming, with every member of Windows Central rocking either an Xbox One console or PC gaming rig. We've compared and contrasted every iteration of Xbox One to bring you this guide. Xbox One X Raw 4K power From $299 at Amazon Pros Has thousands of games 4K media apps, Blu-ray discs, and games IR blaster for TV controls, Amazon Echo for voice controls Improved HDD speeds for faster loading times Cons More expensive at around $500 RRP Requires a 4K TV to get the most out of it The Xbox One X is the world's most powerful games console, running the latest games with the crispest, detailed visuals on TV sets with 4K HDR support. Xbox One S More affordable From $226 at Amazon Pros Has thousands of games 4K media apps and Blu-ray IR blaster for TV controls, Amazon Echo for voice controls More affordable at around $300 RRP Cons No 4K games Games run worse, even on a 1080p TV The Xbox One S i

Elon Musk sends yet another notice trying to terminate the Twitter deal

Kristen Radtke / The Verge; Getty Images Elon Musk has sent a third letter to Twitter attempting to terminate his $44 billion acquisition of the company . Musk’s legal team cited Twitter’s multimillion dollar severance payment to former security chief and whistleblower Peiter Zatko as a violation of the merger agreement and a reason to end the deal. The letter, dated September 9th, was sent to Twitter’s chief legal officer Vijaya Gadde, and was included in a filing Twitter made with the SEC on Friday (which you can read at the bottom of this article). Last month, Zatko made headlines by accusing Twitter of misleading investors about the number of bots on the service, failing to delete users’ data, and having poor security practices, among other things. Musk jumped on the accusations, citing them in his second termination letter and subpoenaing Zatko to testify in the lawsuit. Zatko was set to be deposed on Friday. Elon Musk sent his first letter of termination in July , say